Perhaps NY Times star columnist Thomas Friedman reads Netopia, but then again maybe not. In any case, he now joins in doubting the role of social media in the Arab Spring. For Netopia’s readers, it is no news that there were many more important factors than technology (and most people on Tahrir Square did not have internet access in the first place), as Mariam Kirollos has demonstrated. The myth of the social media revolution lives strong, yesterday I listened to a talk by an executive from Al-Jazeera who made this notion part of his speech. But while Kirollos’s point is that the revolution was driven by bigger forces – the people demanded bread, freedom and social justice – Friedman’s view is more techno-centric. Social media did spark the Arab Spring, but then turned into a vehicle for counter-revolution in Friedman’s account. Two different takes: was social media just a minor impact? Or central both to the regime and the protesters? Regardless, Friedman’s piece is a welcome and long overdue sobering-up from the punch-drunk self-aggrandizing image of Western companies liberating the oppressed through commercial technology. Welcome to the camp of the skeptics and the doubters, Thomas Friedman.
Friedman Questions #SocialMedia in the #ArabSpring
5 February 2016 | Per Strömbäck
Worth Reading
- What Dune Can Tell You about Copyright and Creative Work (bonus: Space Swim Suit) »
- Europe’s Digital Phantom Pains (or: How Start-up Programs Feed the Tech Beast) »
- Feature Creep and the Horror of Opportunity »
- Why Europeans (and Floorball) Benefit from Geo-Blocking »
- Where Did Technology Neutral Go? »
- Move Fast and Ban Things »
- Generative AI – The Hidden Centaur »
- Metaverse or Metaverses? »
- Millimeter Waves Or: Network Tax in Space »
- Would Network Tax Bring Better Broadband? »
- Twitter Exodus and the EEE Playbook »
- Spotify on Netflix Brings out Old Frenemies »
- Putting the Art into ARTificial Intelligence »
- The AI Effect »
- Nobel Laureate Calls Oversight Board “Deflection” – She Is Right and Here Is How »
- So Difficult to Make Good Propaganda these Days »
- The Power of Ownership - Follow Musk »
- Can Copyright Save the Planet? »
- Will Putin’s War Split the Internet? »
- The First Casualty of War »
- Facebook’s Myspace Moment »
- Turns Out SOPA/PIPA Wouldn’t Have Broken the Internet After All »
- Fake Xmas Trees »
- Have You Met a Whistleblower? »
- The (Non-)Democracy Machine – How the Tech Giants Gave in to Kremlin »
Netopia
© Netopia | Forum for the Digital Society | Editor: Per Strömbäck | stromback@netopia.eu