Vote AI in EU Election?

Netopia interviewed ChatGPT4o, Google Gemini and Grok/X AI about their views on digital policy in the European election.

The upcoming EU elections in 2024 will prominently feature several key digital policy issues. These policies are crucial for shaping the future of the digital landscape in Europe. Here are the most important ones:

Q1 What are the most important digital policies in the EU election?

The most important digital policies in the EU election revolve around safeguarding the integrity of the electoral process and promoting a fair and secure digital environment. These include measures to combat disinformation, regulate online platforms, and protect user data. The Digital Services Act (DSA) plays a crucial role in this context, as it imposes obligations on online platforms to address illegal and harmful content, protect user rights, and ensure fair competition. The EU is also focusing on transparency in political advertising and the use of AI in political campaigns to ensure a level playing field and prevent manipulation. Additionally, the European Commission has issued guidelines to Very Large Online Platforms (VLOPs) and Search Engines to protect the integrity of elections from online threats, such as disinformation and cyber-enabled information manipulation. (Grok)

Citing sources, according to ChatGPT4o the most pressing policy areas are:

1. Digital Markets Act (DMA) and Digital Services Act (DSA): These landmark legislations aim to regulate the digital market to ensure fair competition and better user protection. The DMA targets anti-competitive practices by major tech companies, while the DSA focuses on content moderation, transparency, and accountability of online platforms​ (Bruegel)​​ (euronews)​.

2. Artificial Intelligence Act (AI Act): This proposed legislation seeks to create a comprehensive regulatory framework for AI, balancing innovation with ethical considerations and risk management. The act is currently in trilogue negotiations, with a strong interest in reaching a political agreement by the end of 2023​ (Bruegel)​.

3. Data Act: The Data Act is designed to facilitate data sharing across the EU, ensuring fair access and usage of data while protecting user privacy. Political agreement on this act has been reached, and its publication is expected soon​ (Bruegel)​.

4. Cybersecurity and Digital Infrastructure: Strengthening cybersecurity measures and improving digital infrastructure are ongoing priorities. This includes initiatives to enhance cross-border digital networks and accelerate the deployment of high-speed broadband across the EU​ (Bruegel)​.

5. Digital Identity and Privacy: Enhancing digital identity frameworks and revising privacy regulations, such as the ePrivacy Regulation and GDPR, are also on the agenda. These measures aim to provide more robust protection of personal data and privacy rights for EU citizens​ (euronews)​.

Digital Education and Skills: Addressing the digital skills gap and promoting digital education are crucial for ensuring that all citizens can participate fully in the digital economy. This includes initiatives to improve digital literacy and support lifelong learning in digital skills​ (Epthinktank)​.

These digital policies reflect the EU’s commitment to creating a fair, competitive, and secure digital environment for its citizens and businesses. They are expected to be major topics of discussion and debate in the run-up to the elections, influencing both the legislative agenda and voter engagement​ (euronews)​.



Q2 – How do you want to support European digital SMEs?

Supporting European digital SMEs (Small and Medium-sized Enterprises) is crucial for fostering innovation, economic growth, and competitiveness within the EU. Here are several key strategies and initiatives aimed at supporting these businesses:

Access to Finance

EU Funding Programs: The EU offers various funding programs tailored for SMEs, such as Horizon Europe, which focuses on research and innovation, and the Digital Europe Programme, which aims to enhance digital capacities and skills across the EU​ (Epthinktank)​​ (Bruegel)​.

InvestEU: This initiative provides financial support to SMEs through investments in sustainable infrastructure, research, innovation, and digitization projects​ (Bruegel)​.

Regulatory Support

Simplifying Regulations: Efforts to simplify and harmonize regulatory frameworks across member states can reduce the administrative burden on SMEs, making it easier for them to operate and scale within the single market.

Digital Services Act (DSA) and Digital Markets Act (DMA): These acts provide a fairer digital environment by regulating large online platforms and ensuring fair competition, benefiting smaller digital enterprises​ (Bruegel)​​ (euronews)​.

Digital Skills and Training

Digital Skills and Jobs Coalition: This initiative brings together member states, companies, and non-profits to tackle the digital skills gap and provide training and education opportunities for SMEs and their employees​ (euronews)​.

Lifelong Learning Programs: EU programs aimed at continuous education and skill development ensure that SMEs can keep up with rapid technological changes and innovations​ (Epthinktank)​.

Innovation and Research

Horizon Europe: This program supports innovation and research projects, encouraging SMEs to participate in cutting-edge research and collaborate with other entities across Europe​ (Bruegel)​.

European Innovation Council (EIC): The EIC provides funding and support for innovative SMEs, including grants and equity investments for high-risk, high-impact technologies​ (Bruegel)​.

Digital Infrastructure

Improving Connectivity: Investments in digital infrastructure, such as high-speed broadband networks and 5G, are essential for SMEs to thrive in a digital economy. The EU supports various projects to enhance digital connectivity across member states​ (Epthinktank)​​ (euronews)​.

Single Digital Gateway: This initiative aims to provide online access to information, administrative procedures, and assistance services, simplifying cross-border operations for SMEs​ (Bruegel)​.

Networking and Collaboration

Digital Innovation Hubs (DIHs): DIHs offer SMEs access to technology testing, financing advice, market intelligence, and networking opportunities with other businesses and research institutions​ (Epthinktank)​.

European Cluster Collaboration Platform: This platform encourages collaboration among SMEs, large companies, and research organizations within specific sectors, fostering innovation and growth​ (euronews)​.

These measures collectively aim to create a conducive environment for digital SMEs to innovate, grow, and compete on a global scale.



Q3 – How can Europe have a competitive advantage through creativity?

Culture and Creativity as Economic Drivers: Culture and creativity are not just about art and expression; they’re also significant contributors to the EU’s economy. They employ over 7.6 million people and play a vital role in the social, green, and digital transition. So, it’s not just about pretty pictures; it’s about economic growth, too. (Grok)

Creative Europe Program: The EU has a program called Creative Europe that supports the cultural and creative sectors. It’s like a fairy godmother for artists, helping them expand and showcase their talent. (Grok)

Protecting Intellectual Property: Protecting creative work and inventions is crucial for promoting innovation and enabling companies to grow. The EU has made significant reforms to enhance competitiveness and industrial power. So, Europe is not just about croissants and castles; it’s also about protecting your ideas. (Grok)

Collaborative Innovation Networks (COINs): COINs are like the Avengers of creativity, a group of self-motivated people with a collective vision, enabled by technology to collaborate in achieving a common goal—innovation by sharing ideas, information, and work. They’re the most productive engines of innovation ever. (Grok)

Supporting SMEs: The EU is also supporting small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in protecting their innovations and creativity. After all, not all heroes wear capes; some run small businesses. (Grok)

Furthermore, Europe can leverage its rich cultural heritage, diverse talent pool, and strong educational systems to gain a competitive advantage through creativity. Here are several key strategies to achieve this:

Protecting creative work and inventions is crucial for promoting innovation and enabling companies to grow

  • Fostering a Creative Ecosystem:

Cultural and Creative Industries (CCIs): These industries include sectors such as arts, design, media, and entertainment, which are pivotal for innovation and economic growth. Supporting CCIs through funding, policy frameworks, and infrastructure can enhance their global competitiveness​ (Bruegel)​.

Creative Hubs and Incubators: Establishing hubs and incubators that bring together artists, designers, technologists, and entrepreneurs can foster collaboration and innovation. These spaces can provide resources, networking opportunities, and mentorship to creative professionals​ (Bruegel)​.

  • Promoting Cross-Sector Collaboration:

Interdisciplinary Projects: Encouraging projects that combine arts and technology can lead to groundbreaking innovations. For example, integrating digital technologies in the arts can create new forms of artistic expression and business models​ (euronews)​.

Public-Private Partnerships: Collaborations between governments, educational institutions, and private companies can support the development of creative industries by providing funding, resources, and platforms for innovation​ (Epthinktank)​.

  • Investing in Education and Skills:

Creative Education: Enhancing creative education at all levels, from primary schools to higher education, can nurture talent and encourage innovative thinking. Programs that focus on design thinking, digital skills, and artistic creativity are essential​ (Epthinktank)​​ (Bruegel)​.

Lifelong Learning: Continuous professional development and lifelong learning opportunities in creative fields ensure that the workforce remains adaptable and skilled in the latest technologies and methodologies​ (euronews)​.

  • Utilizing Digital Transformation:

Digital Platforms and Tools: Leveraging digital platforms can help creative professionals reach global audiences, market their work, and collaborate internationally. This includes e-commerce platforms, social media, and digital content creation tools​ (Bruegel)​​ (euronews)​

Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Big Data: AI and big data can be used to analyze trends, personalize content, and enhance creative processes. For example, AI can assist in generating music, visual art, and design, providing new tools for creative professionals​ (Bruegel)​.

  • Supporting Intellectual Property (IP) Rights:

IP Protection: Ensuring strong IP rights protection for creative works encourages innovation by safeguarding creators’ investments and efforts. Simplifying the process for obtaining IP protection and increasing awareness about IP rights are crucial steps​ (Epthinktank)​​ (euronews)​.

  • Encouraging Entrepreneurship:

Startup Ecosystems: Supporting creative startups with access to funding, mentorship, and international markets can stimulate innovation and economic growth. Programs like startup accelerators and venture capital investments are essential​ (Bruegel)​.

Access to Markets: Facilitating easier access to both European and global markets for creative SMEs can enhance their competitiveness. Trade agreements, export support, and international collaborations are key components of this strategy​ (euronews)​.

Creativity, when effectively supported and nurtured, can become a significant competitive advantage for the region.

By implementing these strategies, Europe can solidify its position as a global hub for creativity and innovation, leading to a competitive advantage.

Google Gemini answers this question slightly more prolifically. To paraphrase Gemini AI the competitive advantages through creativity are:

The strength of a rich cultural heritage, skilled workers are the strengths of Europe. And there needs to be support from the creative industries. This could involve grants, tax breaks, and infrastructure development. There needs to be collaboration between different creative fields, universities, and businesses to spark cross-pollination of ideas and lead to groundbreaking innovation. A Europe that becomes a leader in developing creative solutions to environmental challenges, like clean technology and sustainable design, while investing in R&D for digital tools and platforms that empower creative expression and innovation can be a major differentiator.
However, to get there, Gemmi points out that there must be less bureaucracy and regulations to encourage creative risk-taking, and funding gaps need plugging.

And it is Google Gemini that has the last line with a proseic prediction, promoting not “digital champions” and outputting that: “By implementing these strategies, Europe can solidify its position as a global hub for creativity and innovation, leading to a competitive advantage.”

And to the only other big question, left to answer: Would you vote for an AI?